The Viscardi Center

at The Viscardi Center

Providing a lifespan of programs and services that educate, employ and empower children and adults with disabilities.
An employer membership organization and comprehensive resource for disability employment best practices.

DONATE

Header Links

  • Login
  • Media Room
  • Contact Us

Share

  • facebook
  • twitter
  • linkedin
  • You Tube
  • Instagram
  • Home
  • Our Services
    • Abilities, Inc.
    • E-Learning
    • Henry Viscardi School
    • National Center for Disability Entrepreneurship
    • Nathaniel H. Kornreich Technology Center
    • Services by Type
    • Services by Age/Audience
    • Services for Businesses
    • How to Obtain Services
  • Our Stories
    • Adults
    • Businesses
    • Children
    • Donors
  • Get Involved
    • Ways to Give
    • Together We Soar Campaign
    • Advocacy
    • Volunteer
    • Share Your Story
    • Viscardi Alumni
  • News & Events
    • News
    • Blog
    • Events
    • Media Room
    • Viscardi Voice Newsletter
  • Digital Accessibility
    • Document Accessibility
    • Web Accessibility
    • Captioning & CART Services
    • Audio Description
    • Viscardi Multimedia Learning Center
  • About
    • History
    • Staff Leadership and Boards of Directors
    • Henry Viscardi Achievement Awards
    • Sunny
    • FAQs
    • Careers
    • Financials
    • Contact Us
www.viscardicenter.org > Viscardi Blog > Education > The Domino Effect

The Domino Effect

August 19, 2019 by Mike Caprara

  • A A A

Why One Major Ruling May Tip the Scales for Digital Accessibility Lawsuits

 August 19, 2019

 Michael Caprara

Dominos being pushed over
Photo Source: https://www.maxpixel.net/

Updated Summer, 2019

As previously reported, the Robles v. Domino’s case has the potential to make waves in the accessibility space, as the Ninth Circuit of Appeals delivered a decision earlier this year allowing the plaintiff to proceed with their digital accessibility lawsuit. On June 13, Domino’s filed a Writ of Certiorari with the United States Supreme Court, essentially asking the court to take the case. Domino’s is asking the Supreme Court to decide if Title III of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) – which guarantees non-discrimination in places of “public accommodation” – requires a website or mobile app to comply with specific, or “discrete” accessibility requirements. The Court should decide in the coming weeks if it will take the case, which would be a landmark for accessibility advocates. We will be continually following up on this developing story.

On January 15, 2019, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, the largest of the thirteen appeals courts in the U.S.1, delivered a groundbreaking decision in favor of the plaintiff in a digital accessibility lawsuit. The suit, Robles v. Domino’s Pizza LLC, alleged that the pizza chain violated the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) by not making its website and mobile applications accessible to users who are blind or low vision2. The case has been closely followed by disability advocates and corporations alike, and the decision may have a lasting impact on digital accessibility legal affairs as well as how companies address accessibility moving forward.

Guillermo Robles is a blind man who “accesses the internet using screen-reading software, which vocalizes visual information on websites.3” Robles alleged that in 2016, he had tried to order a pizza through Domino’s website and app on multiple occasions, and was unable to do so, due to the experiences being inaccessible.
The court’s decision is important for several reasons, but two stand out. First, given that no federal court at this level had previously delivered this kind of ruling, this case stands to set precedent for similar cases all over the country. Second, the case specifically addresses and argues against commonly used defenses in accessibility cases, which should impact similar cases in other courts moving forward.

The ADA prevents discrimination from “places of public accommodation,” which include retail stores, banks, theaters, parks, sports stadiums, etc. Although the ADA does not specifically mention websites or apps as public accommodations, given that it was written before widespread use of the internet, previous court decisions like in Gil v. Winn Dixie have affirmed that websites linked to physical locations are covered4. The decision in the Domino’s case reaffirms and strengthens that precedent on the heels of a Department of Justice (DOJ) notice in 2018 declaring that the ADA covers websites5. This stance has been widely held by accessibility advocates, but now it is affirmed by a major court ruling.

Since the Domino’s suit was filed over two years ago, the case had been dismissed in favor of the defense by a lower court, and subsequently appealed6. The defense argued that the expectation of Domino’s conforming to specific accessibility standards in the absence of specific DOJ guidelines violated their right to due process. This argument had been successfully used by many companies to have other accessibility cases dismissed. The decision from the higher court expressly rejected that argument and could have implications across hundreds of similar cases in the courts for both digital accessibility cases, and others where specific guidelines haven’t been provided by federal agencies.

The internet at its best has the power to connect people and make people’s lives easier. For people with disabilities, technology can be invaluable for quality of life improvements, but they are often excluded from those digital platforms due to poor planning and design.

The importance of the Robles v. Domino’s case cannot be overstated. In a regulatory environment that has been slowed or even reversed since the Department of Justice cancelled much-needed updates for the ADA’s language related to digital accessibility, a decision like this will shift perceptions on these cases, and provide a huge boost for accessibility interests.

As a result of the ruling, Domino’s must now spend the proper time and effort to ensure its website and apps are designed inclusively, and accessible to all users. As more digital accessibility lawsuits pop up, this case will become an incredibly powerful reference point for plaintiffs, defendants, and the courts, that will hopefully tip the scales for digital accessibility.

1https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Court_of_Appeals_for_the_Ninth_Circuit
2https://www.jdsupra.com/legalnews/ninth-circuit-rules-that-lack-of-web-86120/
3https://www.lflegal.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/9th-Circuit-Dominos-Opinion.pdf
4https://www.natlawreview.com/article/cautionary-ruling-website-accessibility-gil-v-winn-dixie-stores
5https://myblindspot.org/2018/10/letter-from-the-department-of-justice-affirming-that-the-ada-covers-websites/
6https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-46894463

Michael Caprara

Michael Caprara

Chief Information Officer, The Viscardi Center
Michael oversees all aspects of technology at The Viscardi Center, where he implements and innovates accessibility for students, staff, and faculty.

Filed Under: Education, Employment, Empowerment

News & Events

  • News

    >

  • Blog

    >

  • Events

    >

  • Media Room

    >

  • Viscardi Voice Newsletter

    >

Blog Categories

  • Empowerment
  • Education
  • Employment

Events

Celebrity Sports Night

Celebrity Sports Night,

Presented by Delta Air Lines

[php snippet=2]

The Mill River Country Club

Save The Date – Annual Golf Outing

[php snippet=2]

View All Events

Related Posts

A graphic with a network of social media and web icons over an image of hands typing on a laptop keyboard

Should WCAG Compliance Be Your Goal?

A man in business attire points to a touchscreen graphic featuring icons representing the legal system.

Web Accessibility Insurance: The Next Frontier

Young professional engaging in a video conference with four colleagues through his laptop.

Answering Your Top Digital Accessibility Questions

Recent Posts

View All >
  • 2022 Games for the Physically Challenged Announced

    April 26, 2022 County Executive Blakeman and Viscardi student athletes announce return of annual Games at Mitchel Field Athletic Complex in June April 26, 2022 ALBERTSON, NY – Nassau County Executive Bruce A. Blakeman and student athletes from the Henry Viscardi School at The Viscardi Center today announced plans for the 2022 Nassau County Games for the Physically [...] Read More...
  • Celebrity Sports Night Returns to In-Person Event

    March 28, 2022 At this signature fundraiser, presented by Delta Air Lines, all-star athletes support vital programs for children and adults with disabilities. March 28, 2022 The Viscardi Center, a network of non-profit organizations providing programs and services that educate, employ, and empower children and adults with disabilities, is holding its 55th annual Celebrity Sports Night live and in person [...] Read More...
  • Save The Date - Annual Golf Outing

    March 11, 2022 Mark Your Calendar to Play a Round of Golf with Us! Date:September 19, 2022 Brunch:10:30 a.m. Shotgun Start:12:00 p.m. Location:The Mill River Club 103 Mill River Rd. Oyster Bay, NY 11771 PURCHASE TICKETS & SPONSORSHIPS Join us for our annual golf outing at The Mill River Club, a private, members-only country club located on Long [...] Read More...
  • Viscardi Awards Honor Leaders with Disabilities

    January 27, 2022 Recognizing innovators, role models, and advocates from around the globe. January 27, 2022 The Viscardi Center — an Albertson, NY-based non-profit organization providing a lifespan of services that educate, employ, and empower people with disabilities — has announced seven recipients of the 2021 Henry Viscardi Achievement Awards. Watch the Awards announcement video now on YouTube. [...] Read More...
  • Recognizing Martin Luther King Jr. Day

    January 17, 2022 January 17, 2022   Today on Martin Luther King Jr. Day, a National Day of Service, we’re reflecting on Dr. King’s commitment to community, empowerment, and the work that must still be done to achieve racial equality. The Viscardi Center’s mission and work are strongly aligned with the values we uphold on MLK Day: diversity, [...] Read More...
  • Students Interview New Viscardi President & CEO

    January 4, 2022 Henry Viscardi School Student Reporters Talk with Dr. Chris Rosa for Cougar Chronicle Special Edition January 4, 2022 Henry Viscardi School student reporters interviewed Dr. Chris Rosa, the new President & CEO of The Viscardi Center, for a special edition of the Cougar Chronicle newspaper. The activity was a way for the students to improve [...] Read More...

Contact Us

The Viscardi Center
National Business & Disability Council at The Viscardi Center
201 I.U. Willets Road
Albertson, NY 11507
516.465.1400
info@viscardicenter.org
Careers at the Viscardi Center | Staff Log in
Accessibility | Privacy | Site Map

Sign up For Enews

The Viscardi Center is a 501(c)(3)
non-profit recognized by the IRS.

Connect With Us

  • facebook
  • twitter
  • linkedin
  • You Tube
  • Instagram

© 2022 The Viscardi Center. All rights reserved. | Designed & Developed by Infinite Media Corp.